ESTHER MENELL'S BLOG

Month: May 2019

TIME TO LEAVE

John McDonnell, May Day rally 2019, Trafalgar Square

When I first saw this photograph, I thought it must be fake.  But it isn’t,  and I cannot understand why it wasn’t plastered all over the papers.

How could John McDonnell, whose economic policies  I would like to see put in place, stand on a platform with a backdrop of two of the greatest mass murderers in history?

Nothing wrong with Marx, nor Engels:  the thinkers, not the doers. Nor even with Lenin, blocked out – as in one of those jokey seaside photo booths – by McDonnell’s own commanding head.

But, Stalin?  Mao?

What has become of the Labour Party?   One of the things that has happened is a leader who seems less and less fit to lead.   The days when Jeremy Corbyn seemed an innocent among the political wolves are long past.

What, after all, is innocent about extending the minimum wage to sixteen-year olds?  A blatantly cynical move to garner the youth vote on which his success depends.

Like the fat boy in the classroom who is no longer made fun of and despised, this perennial backbencher seems to be revelling in his popularity.   But what respect can anyone have for someone who has so little historical sense that when he saw the image below, he did not see what most people could see quite clearly, and later regretted that he ‘didn’t look more closely’?

 

Mear One’s mural ‘Freedom for Humanity’, deleted from an East London wall in 2012

Who wants a leader who talks off the top of his head?   Neither this, nor his having been happy to ‘share a platform’ with Hamas and Hezbollah, while refusing to meet the equally odious Trump, make me think he is an anti-semite.  But his courting universal favour by refusing to break bread with Trump does make me think he is an opportunist.

The initial rapture felt when, like so many lapsed Labour voters, I paid my three pounds and rejoined the party, didn’t last long. Here, I thought, was an honest man, perhaps a fool, but a holy fool.  Now, unable to forget the sight of his second-in-command with Stalin and Mao looking over his shoulder, I see Corbyn as little more than the tool – albeit at times an unruly tool – of people a lot cleverer than he is.

Time to leave.

 

 

A LITTLE LOUDER, PLEASE . . .

As I look at the two smart little bags on the table in front of me, one of which contains Dead Sea beauty products and the other an NHS hearing aid, I am reminded of that ad which was around at a time when advertising, so recently deployed to help win the war, was in its infancy.  For whatever reason – maybe because it asked a question  – I remember Which Twin has the Toni? as vividly as I remember The Squander Bug and Walls Have Ears which, like every war-child, I took to heart, talking in loud whispers in case the enemy was about.

How adults managed to keep their voices down when striving to be heard by the hard-of-hearing elderly, I have no idea. But I am pretty sure that the health service, in its infancy (if it existed at all then), was not handing out these beautifully packaged hearing-aids which I am now trying out for the first time.

So far, the only novelty is that, as I move about, I hear the sound of my feet, also the rustling of the pages of the book I am reading*: a book which reveals, among other tantalising gossip, that professional philosophers are the most spectacular philanderers.  Bertrand Russell (see A QUIET DAY) was not the only one.   ‘Freddie’ Ayers, Stuart Hampshire, Isaiah Berlin were all at it like rabbits, and with each others’ wives and girlfriends.  It seems that my own first husband, who taught the pre-Socratics, was part of a grand tradition.

But, back to ears: what I was looking forward to hearing more clearly was not any old sound but the sound of the human voice.

Not that I have trouble hearing my husband, who was always called on to make announcements in his teaching days, as his voice could be heard above the student din.  But we have a few friends – all men, all big men – who talk so quietly that I can’t hear a thing. Do they keep their voices low so as not to overwhelm with their size?   I imagine there is a parallel in the animal world and that David Attenborough would know the answer.

Be that as it may, it was after an embarrassing evening when I had to pretend to be hearing what was being said and tried to make the appropriate clucking noises, that I went to our GP and asked to be sent to the Ear, Nose and Throat Hospital, in whose catchment area we are lucky to be.

Here, some weeks later, I emerged – diagnosed borderine hard of hearing – from a cosy, sound-proof room, with my bag of goodies which has hung, until today, beside the glossy black bag full of Dead Sea beauty products, which I have also yet to open.

One of those annoying children who always left the best bit to last, I grew into an adult who keeps expensive gifts till they evaporate or grow green with mould.  But my jewel-like hearing-aids aren’t going to be left till their batteries crumble with age. They will, I hope, very soon enable me to hear whatever anyone is saying, however softly they speak.

A House in France by Gully Wells